FacebookTwitterDiggStumbleuponGoogle BookmarksRedditTechnoratiLinkedin

Can It Be Chemical ?

Written by Nicolas Chauvin on .

Often, the main argument of skeptics about excess heat measurement in LENR experiments is that is could be chemical.

So let's dig into the subject, now that we know we can have 71 mg of dihydrogen in the cell.

Let's assume we also have O2 oxygen in the cell and that the reaction is producing H2O from H2 and O2.
This is one of the most exothermic chemical reaction known. It is used to send rockets to the Moon or to Mars.

At 298°K, the bond energies involved are (note that depending on the book, the values can slightly vary):

H-H:   436 kJ/mol
O=O: 495 kJ/mol
H-O-H:   493.5 + 424.4 = 918 kJ/mol

To produce 1 mole of water from 1 mole of H2 and half a mole of O2, the H-H single bond and the O=O dual bond needs to be broken.

Energy to make monoatomic H and O: 436 + 495/2 = 683.5 kJ / mol
Bond energy stored in H2O molecule : 918 kJ/mol
Energy produced: 918 - 683.5 = 234.5 kJ per mole of H2O

As we need 1 mole of H2 to produce 1 mole of H2O and as we have at maximum 0.0352 mole of H2 in the cell,
the maximum chemical energy we can produce is: 0.0352 * 234.5 = 8.25 kJ

However as we do not have O2 in the cell, the best source of oxygen is in the SiO2 of the glass:

Si-O: 368 kJ/mol

Energy to make monoatomic H and O: 436 + 368 = 804 kJ / mol
Bond energy stored in H2O molecule : 918 kJ/mol
Energy produced: 918 - 804 = 114 kJ per mole of H2O

Chemical energy in the cell: 0.0352 * 114 = 4.01 kJ

Even, in very hypothetic worst case scenario, 8.25 kJ corresponds to only 2.29 W·h
And this would mean that the cell pressure would go from 3.5 bars to 0.0 bar while consuming all hydrogen molecules in the cell.
However, this calculation is an approximation using bond energy at ambient temperature. Both temperature and pressure in the cell are affecting the bond energies, but the orders of magnitude are correct.
More details can be found here: Water’s Hydrogen Bond Strength

In conclusion, with our cell, any excess power above 1 watt during multiple hours cannot be chemical.

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Comments   

 
0 #15 Danielgop 2025-04-24 14:02
MEGA - самый крупный магазин в России и СНГ, предлагающий доступ к широкому выбору позиций и безграничным возможностям. Мы обеспечиваем 100% анонимность, скорость и безопасность для каждого пользователя. На нашей площадке ссылки mega вы найдете тысячи диллеров с разнообразными товарами. Поэтому рекомендуем выбирать самые выгодные предложения и внимательно изучать каждого продавца. Мы предлагаем свободный рынок, где конкуренция приводит к лучшим условиям для вас. megaweb777.com
Quote
 
 
0 #14 Normanstere 2025-04-23 12:55
Inspiring story! Ready to act!
Mostbet Sverige - bästa spelupplevelsen online! Registrera dig idag och få en välkomstbonus. ➡️ mostbet se
Clear and concise! Immediately helpful! Mostbet Україна - лідер серед букмекерів! Реєструйся та отримуй бонуси. ➡️ mostbet ua It's incredibly refreshing to encounter content that's this meticulously researched yet remains engaging and accessible throughout.Care er guidance! Upskilling!
Mostbet Казахстан - лучшие ставки на спорт! Регистрируйтесь и получайте бонусы. ➡️ mostbet kazakhstan . Scientific basis! Trustworthy! This content shines brightly in a sea of mediocrity by delivering genuine, substantive value on every single point.
Quote
 
 
0 #13 Normanstere 2025-04-23 05:45
Eco-conscious! Responsible living!
Mostbet France - votre casino en ligne préféré! Profitez des jeux exclusifs et des bonus généreux. ➡️ Visitez Mostbet
Green solution! Planet care! Mostbet зеркало - актуальный вход на сайт! Обход блокировок и стабильная работа. ➡️ мостбет зеркало сегодня The comprehensive nature of this guide means readers get everything they need in one perfectly organized place.Community -focused! Team knowledge!
Mostbet Türkiye'nin en güvenilir bahis sitesi! Hemen giriş yapın ve kazanmaya başlayın. ➡️ mostbet şikayet . Systematic structure! Easy to digest! This isn't just information - it's a complete toolkit for success presented with clarity and authority.
Quote
 
 
0 #12 ug44zef 2025-04-23 03:05
А вы сами согласны тем, как работает такси?
Каждый день всё больше шофёров жалуются на маленький доход, а пассажиры — на качество сервиса. Почему так обстоят дела?
Не следует ли что-то исправлять? dominika-okna.ru/.../

Мы, как профессионалы, считаем, что комфорт и безопасность должны быть приоритетом.
Что считаете? Каким должно быть современное такси в 2025 году?
Расскажите, что думаете — ваше мнение ценно!
Quote
 
 
0 #11 Normanstere 2025-04-22 21:41
Logical flow! Smooth reading!
Mostbet India - best betting platform! Enjoy cricket, slots and live casino games. ➡️ mostbet review
Trusted ways! Worry-free! Mostbet Bangladesh - best betting platform! Enjoy cricket, football and casino games. ➡️ mostbet The innovative approaches suggested here could potentially revolutionize how people approach this subject matter.Cost-eff ective! Smart spending!
Mostbet DE - beste Online-Casinos in Deutschland! Holen Sie sich jetzt Ihren Willkommensbonu s. ➡️ Mostbet DE . Simple language! Anyone can understand! The innovative approaches suggested here could potentially revolutionize how people approach this subject matter.
Quote
 
 
0 #10 Publickt 2025-04-18 01:37
Мы поможем вам обращайтесь Р‘Р°РЅРєРµС‚РЅС ‹Р№ зал СЃ кальяннРѕР№: расслабляющая Р°С‚РјРѕСЃС„РµС ЂР°
Quote
 
 
0 #9 Rickyrix 2025-04-17 05:05
If you're a fan of Sherlock Holmes-style adventures, this Victorian-theme d casino slot will blow you away. Whether you're a casual player or a serious slot fan, this casino experience pulls you into its story with every spin.
This game combines the thrill of casino action with the elegance of classic British mystery.
Ready to uncover the secrets of this unique slot? Start your adventure here: elwkalahgroup.com/.../
Your next favorite online slot might just be this one — themed, thrilling, and full of surprises.
Quote
 
 
0 #8 HarleyTruby 2025-04-15 21:38
Предлагаем вашему вниманию интересную справочную статью, в которой собраны ключевые моменты и нюансы по актуальным вопросам. Эта информация будет полезна как для профессионалов, так и для тех, кто только начинает изучать тему. Узнайте ответы на важные вопросы и расширьте свои знания!
Ознакомиться с деталями - mednarkoforum.ru/
Quote
 
 
0 #7 Christine 2023-08-08 01:51
当記事では、エナジーカジノで受け取れる豊富なボーナスや、特徴などを幅広く解説しています。.



Also visit my web site ... ハイローラーとはカジノで何です か: wiki.unionoframblers.com/.../. ..
Quote
 
 
+1 #6 Ecco 2012-11-21 10:01
@Nicolas Chauvin:

>We tried to improve it by using fused quartz instead of borosilicate glass and it was a mistake.

But nothing would stop the MFMP team trying to wrap the reactor glass tube with one (1) smooth layer of aluminum foil with the shiny side facing the wires, wouldn't it? This should improve IR containment enormously, with the benefit of added quartz glass heat resistance compared to borosilicate, at no added cost.

You don't even need to wrap the glass tube entirely, if you need a "window" for temperature measurements with the IR sensor.

The drawback is that calibration runs will have to be remade from scratch, however.

I'd suggest making a simple test with it as soon as possible on the USA cell to see how much T_Mica changes for a given input power. If as expected, it changes significantly, then it is something worth considering investing time on, performing calibrations and all from scratch.
Quote
 
 
+1 #5 Nicolas Chauvin 2012-11-21 08:59
@Jag Kaurah:
It is in our longer term plans. But we have to go each step at a time. First step is to replicate Celani cell, not to improve it.
We tried to improve it by using fused quartz instead of borsilicate glass and it was a mistake.

@Al Potenza
Very true. Unless we can measure excess heat way above our measurement margin of error, we will not be able to demonstrate anything.
The next generation of the cell will be much easier to fit in a calorimeter. But again, we have to go step by step.
Quote
 
 
+2 #4 Al Potenza 2012-11-20 15:52
In your system, chemical energy is an unlikely cause of excess power or energy. However, absent formal calorimetry, an error of measurement or interpretation of data is possible.

The longer the run and the higher the excess power, the less it is likely, says Captain Obvious.
Quote
 
 
+1 #3 Jag Kaurah 2012-11-20 15:18
why not cram 10 or more Celani wires in and see a much bigger efect?
Quote
 
 
+1 #2 Nicolas Chauvin 2012-11-20 14:46
Indeed, a very legitimate question.

We are trying our best to demonstrate that excess heat can be produced. So far, we still have to solve some design issues before reaching temperature above 300°C where we could hopefully see the effect.
Quote
 
 
+2 #1 Ecco 2012-11-20 14:16
Thanks for the explanation. So, since chemical reactions are ruled out, the question can only be: is the cell actually producing excess heat? Big question.
Quote
 

Here is your generous contributions so far towards our $500,000 target, thanks everyone! : $45,020   Please Donate
See the current state of our booked costs here