Preliminary Assessment of Rossi's Validation Paper
As most of you know by now, there was a report of an independent validation test performed on Andrea Rossi's Ecat this week. (view it here)
Overall positive impression
Our preliminary assessment among the team is that it is a generally good report with no obvious errors or glaring omissions. It is easily the best evidence to date that Rossi has a working technology, and, if verified openly and widely, this report could be remembered as historic.
That's not to say that we feel total confidence in the report, either. It is unfortunate that there are some justified concerns about the independence of the test team, since many of the authors are names that we have seen before in the context of Rossi. Plus, we are disappointed that none of the authors are willing to present at ICCF18 in July, which would certainly be an extremely welcoming audience for such a report, if the details stand up to further scrutiny.
Other technical questions and criticisms
It was good that the authors were satisfyingly conservative when things were in question. Examples include using an emissivity of 1 for the first test, using bottom side of apparatus, including the shadowed areas, and adding an additional 10% for unknown errors.
It was also satisfying that even if they ignored convection and included the control box power, it was still above unity.
The whole COP discussion is rather arbitrary IF the input power goes primarily to heating up the bulk to trigger it thermally, as it appears. A little insulation - or better, yet, an adjustable cooling system, might allow the device to run at or near self sustaining.
However, some things about the input power measurement aren't entirely clear. A block diagram of the wiring and instrumentation points would clarify where they were measuring the power input from at different points in the experiment. Some screen captures of the wave form on the power input would be stronger indication that it was something the power analyzer could accurately measure. Rossi has mentioned using frequencies to stimulate the reaction to occur. If the frequency of that was high enough, the power meter may not "see" the power delivered by that part of the wave form. If the control box was putting out that sort of signal for the live run and the "dummy" run, though, the dummy run would have appeared to show excess energy, which is good that it did not according to the report. However, the active load may interact in a way that allows high frequency power use while the resistive load does not. It is not clear from the report if the control box was used in the dummy mode in the same way it was during the active run.
The specs for the power meter used are here: http://www.industrial-needs.com/technical-data/power-anlayser-PCE-830.htm
I'm not very convinced by the heating cycle shape argument - that is a system with a lot of non-linearities and multiple time constants involved. I think more tests, or comparison to the temperature curves of the "dummy" unit, and with varying controlled heater power cycles would be a more valid comparison.
One further takeaway was that it seamed from this report, that this reactor design is difficult to control at the higher COPS. Strong evidence of this is the failure of the first test. This may be due to the nature of close location of nano particles in the fuel mix but may be effectively resolved by better thermal extraction as mentioned above.
Call for more openness to prove this to the world definitively
We, the MFMP, on behalf of the global population, call on the authors and Andrea Rossi to make the raw data and more detailed instrumention details for the entire test available for verification of calculations made form the data. We are willing to host the data and help stimulate the analysis of it, or simply be another participant re-analyzing it.
This publication raises the bar for Defkalion, Brillouin, and anybody else claiming a valid technology to present something more compelling, also.
Many comments in the LENR blogosphere have suggested that the MFMP would be a good, independent, trust worthy validator. We are honoured by these views and would certainly be eager to help facilitate any further validation tests for Rossi, Defkallion, or Brillouin etc. in any way that would ensure the facts are established whilst the IP of the originator is wholly protected.
Comments
write a little comment to support you.
Here is my webpage: Cherry Charm: play.google.com/.../...
familiarity, therefore it's fastidious to read this blog, and I
used to visit this webpage all the time.
Visit my web-site :: SongAI: apps.apple.com/.../...
blanchiment d’argent.
massive amount work? I have absolutely no expertise in computer programming however I was
hoping to start my own blog soon. Anyway, should you have
any suggestions or tips for new blog owners please share.
I know this is off topic but I simply had
to ask. Thanks a lot!
Feel free to visit my page ... проститутки дыбенко: komunitas.dukcapil.id/.../...
I have read this post and if I could I want
to suggest you some interesting things or advice.
Maybe you can write next articles referring to this article.
I want to read even more things about it!
Feel free to visit my blog :: สล็อตเว็บตรง: g2g168p-วอ-เลท.coole r.kc9.abtbungbon.go.th/
рассказать собственную историю успеха о похудение
после родов, что и как я делала, кто мне в этом помогал.
Вначале немного о себе. Меня зовут Наталия.
Сейчас мне 38 лет, год и два месяца назад я родила
малыша, путём кесарева сечения.
Животик был огромный , мальчик родился на 4700
кг, 56 см. Сейчас я ещё кормящая мама,
но мой малыш с года уже никак не хочет лежа
кушать, поэтому просто сцеживаю
ему молоко.Я знаю, что все мамочки очень хотят похудеть после родов, привести себя
в форму и убрать живот. Вот и мне безумно надоело
в какой-то момент это безобразие:
вещи не сходятся, купить новые нет ни лишних
денег, ни времени, постоянная усталость и занятость ребенком,
в зеркале видишь тётю с животом
и складками на боках! Ну просто кошмар!
Вообщем, к 11 месяцу после родов, я поняла, что больше так жить не
могу! Я очень захотела и решила месяц похудеть: pro-gribki.ru/.../... и привести себя в порядок
и я начала делать конкретные шаги и постепенно сформировала для себя каждодневные действия.
В результате минус 8 кг и минус 13 см в талии за полтора месяца.
Вот что я начала делать:1. В виду
того, что самооценка после родов резко
начала падать, я стала заниматься аутотренингом.
В тот момент , когда я умываюсь, говорю себе, глядя в зеркало, что
я красивая, здоровая, худая,
что никогда не переедаю. Я убедилась, что это работает,
почему-то перестала переедать,
стала чувствовать себя лучше и гораздо
увереннее. Где-то читала, что наиболее эффективно заниматься аутотренингом,
засыпая и просыпаясь. Если не
забываю, то когда ложусь спать тоже мысленно
себе это говорю. Советую всем попробовать!2.
Питание. Это диета кормящей мамы, нельзя острое, солёное,
копчёное, пряное. К тому же, чтобы как-то сэкономить время, питаюсь в одно
время с ребёнком. Мой малыш кушает 5 раз в день и я с ним.
Кушаю немного и главное снова НЕ ПЕРЕЕДАТЬ!
Это очень важно! Ещё важный
момент следить, что не было тяжести в животе, т.е.
покушали и в животе осталась лёгкость.
Есть ещё проблема я ужасная сладкоежка и поэтому, решила,
что кушать сладкое я буду до 18.00 (можно после 18.00 2 плитки горького шоколада, только осторожней,
если вы кормите), а последний приём пищи в 21.00.
Таким образом за завтраком и
за обедом ем сладкое сколько
хочется. Вечером, по совету Виктории Раз, кушаю белковую пищу мясо с овощами, курочку.3.
Я познакомилась с Викторией Раз в группе Успевай с детьми ВКонтакте.
Она мне порекомендовала делать массаж живота делаю 3-4 минуты два раза в день.
Это очень помогает! Талия моя,
после родов была 90 см, растаяла просто на глазах!
Только слишком сильно делать не
стоит, чтобы кожа не растянулась и, конечно,
с маслом, с любым обязательно.4.
Прогулка. Ходьба очень хорошо
сжигает калории. Я гуляла с коляской
1-1,5 часа в день, просто ходила всё
это время. Этого достаточно и мне и малышу.
А теперь ещё и бегаю за ним по площадке :)).5.
Тайм-менеджмент. Не секрет, что с малышами очень мало времени у мамы, но
есть такая классная штука, как тайм-менеджмент.
Я не строю никаких систем для себя,
я просто читаю электронную версию журнала Успевай с детьми и пользуюсь
чужими советами, как распределить время так, что его ещё осталось и на
себя.
reporting! Keep up the terrific works guys I've you guys to
my own blogroll.
Review my blog: Best Cheap Proxies: Extraproxies.com/.../...
if that would be ok. I'm absolutely enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.
My homepage online casino
sign up bonus: flickr.com/.../...
The clarity for your put up is just cool and that i can assume you are a profesional on this subject.
Well along with your permission allow me to clutch your
RSS feed to keep up to date with drawing close post.
Thank you a million andd please continue the enjoyable work.
My blog :: Blazing
Proxies: Proxies123.com/
it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and help others like you aided
me.
Feel free to surf to my blog post; p7317: accept-forum.enfocus.com/.../
Она использует современные методы и техники, чтобы помочь своим клиентам справиться
с такими проблемами как клинический
психолог: anna-chernikova.ru/ и другими проблемами.
You are very intelligent. You know thus considerably in relation to this topic, made me in my
view believe it from so many numerous angles.
Its like men and women are not interested except it is
one thing to accomplish with Lady gaga! Your own stuffs outstanding.
All the time maintain it up!
Here is my web site :: no deposit bonus online casino: bbs.t-firefly.com/.../
with? I'm planning to start my own blog in the near future
but I'm having a difficult time selecting between BlogEngine/Word press/B2evoluti on and Drupal.
The reason I ask is because your design seems different then most blogs and
I'm looking for something completely unique. P.S Sorry for being off-topic but I had to ask!
Here is my webpage online casino no deposit bonus: www.ezega.com/.../Fritid
current at this web page is genuinely excellent.
Check out my webpage خرید دوربین هایک
ویژن: sites.google.com/.../...
Where else could I get that type of info written in such an ideal manner?
I've a venture that I'm just now working on, and I've been at the look out for such information.
Review my website clarefondacash. com: clarefondacash.com/
The clearness for your put up is just great
and i can suppose you're an expert on this subject. Fine along with your permission let me to grasp your RSS feed to
keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks
one million and please keep up the rewarding work.
Also visit my web blog - Fast Proxies: 100Proxies.com/
ever run into any internet browser compatibility issues?
A few of my blog audience have complained about my website not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Firefox.
Do you have any suggestions to help fix this problem?
Review my homepage ... free play online casino: https
UK.
Here is my web site: mi tower scaffold: diigo.com/0vviqz
RSS feed for comments to this post